Opens in a new tab

Dissolution of the Advisory Commission

Building design
Minister of State for Culture Claudia Roth. Photo: J. Konrad Schmidt

Minister of State for Culture Claudia Roth.
Photo: J. Konrad Schmidt

The Advisory Commission, which is supposed to mediate in conflicts over the restitution of artworks confiscated as a result of Nazi persecution, has been criticized for some time. Now it is to be dissolved, as its members were informed at a meeting in the Chancellery at the end of May. It is to be replaced by an arbitration tribunal.

The Advisory Commission, which is supposed to mediate in conflicts over the restitution of artworks confiscated as a result of Nazi persecution, has been criticized for some time. Now it is to be dissolved, as its members were informed at a meeting in the Chancellery at the end of May. It is to be replaced by an arbitration tribunal.

The “Advisory Commission in connection with the restitution of cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution, in particular Jewish property”, also known as the Limbach Commission, was established in 2003. Its purpose was to mediate in conflicts between the heirs of Jewish collectors and German museums regarding the restitution of Nazi-looted property and to contribute to “fair and just solutions” in accordance with the Washington Declaration of 1998. In the approximately 20 years of its existence, it has been called upon 24 times to make its recommendations, which are not legally binding. The fact that the Commission has been called upon so rarely may also be due to the fact that it can only be called upon by mutual agreement. This fact has often led to displeasure among heirs. The case of the painting “Madame Soler”, which Pablo Picasso painted in 1903, is probably well known. The painting is owned by the Bavarian State Painting Collection and the state of Bavaria refuses to consult the Advisory Commission in a dispute with the descendants of the Mendelssohn banking family. This case shows how things should not be done and was also strongly criticized at an international conference in Washington and at a hearing of the Bundestag’s Culture Committee.
Nevertheless, it should not be forgotten that many museums and heirs were able to come to an agreement without the help of the Advisory Commission and that many restitutions are carried out quietly in the spirit of a “fair and equitable solution”. Other points of criticism of the Commission’s work were that it worked too slowly and that its decisions were not transparent. The Commission took this as an opportunity to redesign its rules of procedure in 2016. The decision to dissolve the commission was taken at the 20th Cultural Policy Summit in March of this year. Claudia Roth invited the members of the Commission to a meeting at the Federal Chancellery at the end of May to inform them that the dissolution would now be completed. Originally, the coalition parties FDP, Greens and SPD had agreed to reform the committee in the 2021 coalition agreement. How to proceed after the end of the Advisory Commission is to be worked out in a corresponding concept by the beginning of October and decided by the federal, state and local authorities as soon as possible.

According to media reports, one of the invited commission members felt that the conversation with Roth was a farce. They were allowed to raise objections to the end of the Consultative Commission and were also asked to continue with their work. However, the decision to dissolve it was not abandoned. The originally planned strengthening of the Advisory Commission, which the Greens, FDP and SPD had agreed, has therefore been canceled. This is despite the fact that, according to media reports, Minister of State for Culture Claudia Roth stated that they wanted to avoid the descendants of people who were robbed by the National Socialists having to act as petitioners. The plan was for the Commission to be able to initiate proceedings independently in order to avoid cases such as the one in Bavaria with the Picasso painting “Madame Soler”. Instead of taking this reform step, Claudia Roth, representatives of the federal states and municipal umbrella organizations decided back in March to “replace the Commission with an arbitration tribunal”. Hans-Jürgen Papier, who has chaired the Advisory Commission since 2017, has long warned that Germany is not sufficiently fulfilling its obligation to the Washington Agreement. This is also due to the fact that the Commission is too weak in its current form. However, abolishing the committee was certainly not in his interest. Especially as, according to media reports, it gives pause for thought that arbitration tribunals are hardly conceivable without double consent and that a promise of unilateral appeal can therefore not be kept. As former President of the Federal Constitutional Court, he knows what he is talking about. According to media reports, he also suggested that such an institution still had to be established. Both human and financial resources would have to be made available for this. Until this had been done, proceedings would have to be put on hold. He was of the opinion that the commission should be transformed from an advisor into a decision-maker, as Deutschlandfunk found out. Once again, demands for a restitution law are being voiced by representatives of the Jewish Claims Conference, among others, as was reported in the Jüdische Allgemeine. The Bavarian Minister of Culture Markus Blume is also calling for such a law and has launched a Bundesrat initiative to this end. At a hearing of the Committee for Culture and Media in March, however, there was a mixed response to such a law. However, the fact that the Advisory Commission was still being worked on at the time was a cause for concern. The decision to dissolve the Commission came as a surprise two days after the committee hearing. It now remains to be seen how the Federal Government intends to regulate the restitution of art and cultural assets seized as a result of Nazi persecution in the future. However, all those involved agree that Germany in particular needs a regulation, especially as it has committed itself to the Washington Principles.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

German Prize for Monument Protection 2017 announced

Building design

The German National Committee for Monument Protection has once again announced the “German Prize for Monument Protection” for 2017. The German Prize for Monument Protection is awarded annually and is the highest award in this field in the Federal Republic of Germany. It was established in 1977 by the German National Committee for Monument Protection to recognize individuals and groups of people who have shown exemplary […]

“Stones of Bern” presents the history of architecture and guides you through the city

Building design

Toni Labhart and Konrad Zehnder have spent decades researching and present their knowledge in the illustrated book and excursion guide “STEIN of Bern”. Well done to those who have a passion, because they always have something to tell. Toni Labhart, a former lecturer in rock science, and Konrad Zehnder, an employee at the Swiss Geotechnical Commission, share a passion for Bern’s stone architecture. And they […]

Toni Labhart and Konrad Zehnder have spent decades researching and present their knowledge in the illustrated book and excursion guide “STEIN of Bern”.

Blessed is he who has a passion, for he always has something to tell. Toni Labhart, former lecturer in rock science, and Konrad Zehnder, employee at the Swiss Geotechnical Commission, share a passion for Bern’s stone architecture. And they talk about it together in the recently published book Steine Berns. Not least to show the stony diversity of the city, which is by no means only made of sandstone.

The cover announces “A geological journey of discovery through the built city”, and the reader can approach this journey from two sides: Volume 1 is a richly illustrated book on the architectural history and geology of Bern. It explains the choice of stone for a total of 113 buildings – churches, fountains, bridges, etc. – their origin and application. Volume 2 is the “implementation” in practice, so to speak: an excursion guide through the city, with eight elaborate tours. They lead, for example, through Bern’s south side, look at the city’s main axis and present buildings and quarries in the surrounding area that are well worth a visit. However, if you want, you can also use the guide to put together your own themed tours, for example just visiting the fountains or all the buildings made of limestone tuff.

Labhart and Zehnder show how natural stone reflects the development of the town. After a major fire in 1405, the city’s rulers ordered Bern to be rebuilt in stone. Specifically, sandstone, which is found in the region in different variations, such as granite sandstone, slab sandstone and Fribourg sandstone. It was initially quarried near the city, followed later by the development of quarries on the Gurten, in Ostermundigen and east of Bern. In addition, shell limestone, limestone tuff and granite. They are used, for example, as building plinths, for which the Bernese sandstone is too susceptible to moisture.

From the age of the railroad onwards, materials from more distant regions also began to shape the cityscape. One example of this is the use of polished black limestone on one of the three main portals of the Heiliggeistkirche. The “sandstone city” of Bern is more diverse than is often assumed, as the authors also want to show. According to them, over 70 types of stone can be found in Bern’s architecture, making the city the “richest in stone” in Switzerland.

In their book, Labhart and Zehnder combine geological facts and cultural and architectural history with guided walks through the city in an exciting and easy-to-understand way. The double volume is published by the main publishing house with 200 and 180 pages and costs 68 euros.