Opens in a new tab

How are the costs of additional services, contract changes, and increases in quantity calculated?

Building design
Former adjunct professor of construction law in Munich. Photo: private collection
Former adjunct professor of construction law in Munich. Photo: private collection

New Case Law: If changes to the scope of work or increases in quantities occur during contract execution, and the contracting parties have entered into a VOB contract, the following principle previously applied: “A good price remains a good price; a bad price remains a bad price.” In plain language: Even for a mandated contract amendment or for increases in quantities for individual line items, the price for these services must be calculated based on the pricing principles of the main bid. If these are favorable, the price in the amendment remains favorable as well. If the initial prices are poor, the contractor may have to cover the difference. This principle has now been “overturned” by case law.

Attorney Dr. Olaf Hofmann, former lecturer in construction law in Munich. Photo: private

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) had to rule on the following case:

In a VOB unit-price contract for the performance of facade work, the “facade insulation” item resulted in additional quantities of well over ten percent. In its final invoice, the contractor also charged the “very favorable” contractually agreed unit price and invoked § 2(3)(2) VOB/B, according to which the contractual unit price also applies to the additional quantities. Only if savings can be identified or if the contractor can prove additional costs (for example, higher purchase prices for materials or higher labor costs) does this contractual base price change. Since neither savings nor additional costs were incurred, the contractual price therefore applies.

Is the contractor correct?

The Decision In its judgment of November 21, 2019 (Baurechts-Report 2020, p. 1), the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) stated the following:
1. The right to establish a new price is contingent only on the quantity performed exceeding the quantity specified in the contract by more than 10% and one party demanding that a new price be agreed upon.

2. If the contracting parties cannot agree on the new price, the new price for the additional quantity is determined “based on the actual costs incurred plus reasonable surcharges.”

Practical Notes

1. The VOB principle “A good price remains a good price; a bad price remains a bad price” is therefore no longer valid.
2. This principle naturally applies not only when the contractor has a “good” unit price, but also, for example, when the contractor has miscalculated the contract price to his disadvantage. He may now demand a reasonable price for the additional quantity, i.e., calculate it based on “actual costs incurred.”
3. There have since been additional court rulings stating that the pricing principles used to determine the previous contract price are no longer decisive for calculating the price of additional services and contract amendments. Rather, the new price is also based on the “actual costs incurred” (see Higher Regional Court of Brandenburg, April 22, 2020, Baurechts-Report 2020, p. 22).

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Renaissance II – Painting and Sculpture

Building design
The Creation of Adam is one of the most outstanding works of art of the Renaissance. Photo: Public domain, via: Wikimedia Commons

The Creation of Adam is one of the most outstanding works of art of the Renaissance.
Photo: Public domain, via: Wikimedia Commons

The Renaissance marked an era of profound intellectual and artistic renewal. In painting and sculpture, artists discovered the human being as the measure of all things – as a physical, thinking and feeling being. Between science and spirituality, an art emerged that united beauty, knowledge and human dignity in an unprecedented way.

The Renaissance revolutionized painting and sculpture by focusing on people in their physical, mental and emotional dimensions. Artists such as Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo and Raphael combined anatomical studies, mathematical perspective and differentiated lighting to create a new, realistic visual language. This article examines key works of the Renaissance and shows how the observation of nature, humanism and scientific thinking led to a new view of the human being.

The Renaissance marked the beginning of a profound and almost revolutionary change in the visual arts. Artists no longer strove for pure symbolism or idealized transcendence, but for a convincing naturalism, a spatial perspective and a depiction of man that was both idealized and individual. Painting and sculpture did not merely serve aesthetic purposes, but were carriers of humanism, religious awareness, philosophical thought and social ideals. Art became a mirror of the newly discovered self-confidence of man, who saw himself as the measure of all things.

Michelangelo Buonarroti (1475-1564) is considered the epitome of the Renaissance artist who set standards in painting, sculpture and architecture alike. With his famous “David” (1501-1504, Florence, Galleria dell’Accademia), he created far more than just a statue – he created a symbol of human strength, spiritual greatness and republican self-confidence. The sculpture combines perfect anatomical precision with inner tension, calm and heroic dignity. It embodies the ideal of the “uomo universale”, the all-round educated and self-determined human being who experiences body and mind in harmonious unity.
In the ceiling painting of the Sistine Chapel (1508-1512, Rome), Michelangelo combined painting and sculpture in an overwhelming theological and artistic program. Scenes from Genesis – such as the famous “Creation of Adam” – show the dynamic, almost electric relationship between God and man. The figures appear sculpturally modelled, the volume of their bodies emphasized by sculptural lighting. In his later “Last Judgement” (1536-1541), Michelangelo heightened this vision to a dramatic level: movement, emotion and spiritual shock permeate the entire pictorial field.

Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519) was not only an outstanding artist, but also a researcher, inventor and anatomist. He understood painting as a science of seeing and knowledge. His meticulous studies of muscles, bones and proportions formed the basis for a depiction of the human body that was based on observation and knowledge. The famous “Vitruvian Man” (c. 1490, Venice) follows the rules of proportion of the ancient architect Vitruvius and symbolizes the harmony of man, nature and the cosmos – a symbol of universal order. In “The Last Supper” (1495-1498, Santa Maria delle Grazie, Milan), Leonardo perfected central perspective and created an unprecedented unity of space, light and gesture. Each figure reacts individually to the words of Christ – doubt, fear, faith and knowledge are reflected in their faces. This transforms the biblical events into a deeply human, even psychologically tangible scene that draws the viewer directly into the drama.

Raffaello Santi (1483-1520) brought the humanism of the Renaissance into a new, harmonious form. In his famous “School of Athens” (1509-1511, Apostolic Palace, Vatican), art, philosophy and architecture merge into an ideal image of spiritual order. The symmetrical composition, clearly structured and masterfully constructed in perspective, shows the great philosophers of antiquity – Plato, Aristotle and others – as embodiments of human thought and research. This fresco is considered an allegory of knowledge, education and reason. Raphael also combined spiritual sublimity with human closeness in his paintings of the Madonna, such as the “Madonna di Foligno” (1511-1512). Mary appears as a loving mother, but at the same time as a symbol of divine purity and beauty. This combination of naturalness and ideality made Raphael’s works the epitome of classical harmony.

Masaccio (1401-1428) is considered one of the decisive pioneers of the early Renaissance. With his “Trinità” (1425-1428, Santa Maria Novella, Florence), he laid the foundation for the development of perspective painting. Through mathematically constructed architecture and realistic lighting, he created the impression of spatial depth and physical presence. Masaccio’s work marked the definitive departure from the two-dimensional style of the Middle Ages and the dawn of a rational, three-dimensional understanding of the image.

The Renaissance marked the beginning of a conscious turn towards the individual portrayal of people. The portrait became an expression of personal identity and social status. It not only showed external resemblance, but was also intended to reflect rank, education and character. Nobles, scholars and wealthy citizens – for example in the portraits of Leonardo, Raphael or Hans Holbein the Younger – presented themselves as thinking, self-confident personalities. The portrait thus became a medium of self-knowledge and representation of the new image of man.

The technical achievements of the Renaissance also made a decisive contribution to their success. The development of oil painting, especially in northern Italy by artists such as Antonello da Messina, made softer transitions, finer nuances and greater atmospheric depth possible. Fresco and tempera techniques were further refined to create monumental, narratively complex programs. In sculpture, bronze and marble allowed a precise rendering of movement, texture and anatomy – from Donatello’s youthful “David” to Michelangelo’s powerful monumentality.

Renaissance art unites three spheres in a unique way: Humanism, theology and natural science. The depiction of man became a form of knowledge – an expression of divine order as well as a sign of intellectual curiosity. Anatomy, perspective and light were seen as a means of searching for truth and realizing spiritual perfection. For today’s art historians and restorers, the challenge remains to understand these works not only technically, but also ideologically and philosophically.
Renaissance painting and sculpture fundamentally renewed European art. Masters such as Michelangelo, Leonardo, Raphael and Masaccio combined scientific thought, theological reflection and aesthetic sensibility to form a new unity. Man became the focus of representation – as a physical, spiritual and moral being. The ideals of the Renaissance, characterized by harmony, knowledge and creative freedom, still shape the Western understanding of beauty and art today.

Mobility in the metropolitan region

Building design

Students present alternative mobility concepts in Munich Growing traffic volumes, increasing commuter flows – the Munich metropolitan region is groaning under the increasing traffic load. New ideas are needed! In cooperation with the association Europäische Metropolregion München e.V. (EMM), around 50 students from Munich University of Applied Sciences developed innovative concepts for mobility issues in the metropolitan region. The results of the semester project will be presented between the […]

Students present alternative mobility concepts in Munich

Growing traffic volumes, increasing commuter flows – the Munich metropolitan region is groaning under the increasing traffic load. New ideas are needed! In cooperation with the association Europäische Metropolregion München e.V. (EMM), around 50 students from Munich University of Applied Sciences developed innovative concepts for mobility issues in the metropolitan region. The results of the semester project will be exhibited at PlanTreff, Munich, between September 22 and November 25, 2016.

In three and a half months, students from nine faculties developed alternative mobility concepts. The university worked closely with the EMM: In exchange with partners from the field, the students took an interdisciplinary approach to an area almost as large as Belgium. The diversity of the nine final concepts is impressive: they range from futuristic hybrid double-decker buses to potential high-speed cycle path corridors between Munich and Garching.

Exhibition opening

September 21, 2016, 6.30 pm
PlanTreff Munich (Blumenstraße 31, Munich)
City Planning Councillor Prof. Dr.(I) Elisabeth Merk and Prof. Dr. Klaus Kreulich, Vice President of Munich University of Applied Sciences, will speak.

Exhibition

September 22 to November 25, 2016
PlanTreff Munich (Blumenstraße 31, Munich)
Monday to Friday, 8 am to 6 pm, free admission