Isarphilharmonie Munich: From temporary quarters to a sound miracle

Building design
HP8 site with Hall E, Isarphilharmonie München, Munich University of Music and Performing Arts, Munich Adult Education Center, event hall and Freiraum Forum. Photo: HG Esch, © & Courtesy gmp.

HP8 site with Hall E, Isarphilharmonie München, Munich University of Music and Performing Arts, Munich Adult Education Center, event hall and Freiraum Forum. Photo: HG Esch, © & Courtesy gmp.

The new Isarphilharmonie concert hall in Munich was to be an interim solution for the Bavarian capital’s philharmonic orchestra and its international guest artists, who give around 80 concerts a year here. The Gasteig cultural building on Rosenheimerstrasse, which had been used intensively for thirty years and opened in 1984 and was once home to the Munich Philharmonic Orchestra, was due for a general refurbishment. So where to put the world-class classical and contemporary music concerts and the other facilities that were housed in the Gasteig?

It is still unclear when the Gasteig will be completely renovated. But a good solution has been found: An almost derelict inner-city site on the Isar in the Sendling district was suitable for conversion and expansion, and in just 18 months of construction, the Isarphilharmonie München was opened to plans by Gerkan Marg and Partners (gmp ). It quickly won the hearts of its users, musicians and audiences. Even without a concert, a tour of Munich’s new cultural quarter is well worthwhile. Many visitors even regret that it was only built as an interim solution.

Few districts in Munich are as intensively affected by new neighborhood planning as Sendling. Once an industrial location, a working-class district and, with many cooperative buildings, a simple neighborhood for small people, many new buildings and chic commercial spaces typical of the 21st century are to be built here in the near future. The Isarphilharmonie München, with its cultural and educational buildings, is a trendsetter for the future of the district. Hans-Preißinger-Straße 8 is the exact address of the Isarphilharmonie München. With the initials of the street name, which honors the late leading SPD local politician Hans Preißinger, and the house number 8, the cultural area with the concert hall was also given its official name: HP8. The Isarphilharmonie München is not quite as conveniently located for the city’s music lovers as the Gasteig, but is nevertheless very much in vogue and well attended. Coming from Brudermühlstrasse or Schäftlarnstrasse, the visitor first encounters an existing building on the site, Hall E. This is the disused transformer hall of the former municipal utility site on the Isar, which today also houses the foyer of the Isarphilharmonie München. It is located just a stone’s throw from Hall E. A few steps further on, the University of Music and Performing Arts and the Munich Adult Education Center have moved in. Behind Hall E and the concert hall facing the Isar, there is another event hall. All new buildings have been constructed using the time-saving modular construction method.

The cultural quarter with the Isarphilharmonie Munich and the surrounding cultural and educational buildings is an urban planning project by gmp. The existing building, Hall E in the original industrial style from 1929 with a façade of red brick and grey concrete, has been retained as the center and entrance to the area. The HP8 design has given it a new lease of life in Munich’s cultural scene: with its imposing building height and atrium-like space lit from above with surrounding galleries structured horizontally by blue balustrades, it almost looks like a cathedral. People can move around the open floors and use the various facilities. In addition to the foyer of the Isarphilharmonie Munich on the first floor, these include a location for the Munich City Library, seminar and meeting rooms, rooms for cultural education, catering and a further event hall. Hall E and the concert hall are separated by a gap that is bridged by a narrow connecting structure. The joint construction allows the old and the new to stand side by side: The façade of Hall E remains visible, history and the present become a tangible unit in the Isarphilharmonie München.

“An audience that sees well also hears well,” said Yasuhisa Toyota at the opening of the Isarphilharmonie Munich. Yasuhisa Toyota is the President of Nagata Acoustic in Tokyo, a company that is one of the world’s leading pioneers in sound architecture. Nagata Acoustic has been responsible for the most important concert halls in the world, including the Elbphilharmonie in Hamburg and the House of Hungarian Music in Budapest. Yasuhisa Toyota’s art and his team’s technical know-how can be found in the concert hall of the Isarphilharmonie in Munich. From the very beginning of the planning process, gmp worked with Yasuhisa Toyota and his team to develop the geometry of the space from an acoustic perspective. The sawtooth-like, largely overlapping arrangement of the prefabricated elements and their rough surface in combination with the shape of the stage area, the rising parquet floor and the seating result in a precisely coordinated interplay of sound-reflecting surfaces. The wood-clad walls have a dark glaze, creating a calm and intimate atmosphere despite the public nature of the venue. The audience sees the stage as a bright solitaire – their attention is focused on it and the sound of the music.

The new building by gmp for 1,900 concertgoers consists of two structurally separate systems. The centerpiece of the Isarphilharmonie Munich is the concert hall, built using a time-saving modular timber construction method, which is fitted into an external steel structure. Together with the structural engineers schlaich bergermann partner sbp, gmp developed the hall as a plug-in system made of solid timber elements. These were prefabricated at the same time as the outer steel structure was being erected and then joined together on site. The use of single-shell ceiling and wall elements greatly reduced the construction time. Once the Isarphilharmonie Munich has completed its task as interim accommodation, the modular concert hall can be dismantled and its building materials reused elsewhere.

Read more about another great building that Munich has: the Olympic Stadium.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Building with systems: The Baumeister in August 2022

Building design
In August, B8 "Building with systems", we look at residential construction on a larger scale. You can read more about the individual projects here. The cover photo of B8 is by Hendrik Lietmann

The cover photo of B8 is by Hendrik Lietmann, Ostkreuz.

Better big? Residential construction on a larger scale does not usually have a good reputation. However, it is clear that new living space is needed, especially in cities. In addition, the aspect of sustainability in construction is becoming increasingly important. You can find out whether large-scale residential construction can offer a solution to these challenges in the August issue. Read more in the editorial by Editor-in-Chief Fabian Peters.

Better big? Residential construction on a larger scale does not usually have a good reputation. However, it is clear that new living space is needed in cities in particular. In addition, the aspect of sustainability in construction is becoming increasingly important. You can find out whether large-scale residential construction can offer a solution to these challenges in the August issue. Read more in the editorial by Editor-in-Chief Fabian Peters.

Lack of living space

“We need to build more apartments!” This is apparently the majority opinion among politicians. The not-so-new German government has taken up this goal and written it into the coalition agreement. “We must hardly build any more, if at all”, say climate researchers and environmental activists, referring to the enormous amounts of energy consumed in the process. One thing is certain: If the answer to the lack of living space in metropolitan areas, especially affordable living space, can only be new construction, then small apartment buildings or even single-family homes will not be an option. We need to plan and build in large formats. And as little energy as possible must be used in the process. This can be achieved by using sustainable materials and building as efficiently as possible. Industrial construction methods could play a key role in the future.

The fate of large buildings

Industrial construction? For many, the images of large housing estates in both East and West immediately spring to mind. In West Germany, these neighborhoods were the epitome of social hotspots – and in many cases still are today. Much has now been achieved through neighborhood management. Nevertheless – whether Chorweiler, Neuperlach, Gropiusstadt or Märkisches Viertel, these are addresses that still have a stigma attached to them. Can new large-scale residential buildings escape the fate of their predecessors from the sixties and seventies? Or will we have a new Pruitt-Igoe moment in 25 years’ time?

Building on a larger scale as a solution to the lack of living space?

For this issue, we looked at different concepts for large-scale residential construction, talked to experts about technologies and strategies, and looked at projects and experiences in our neighboring countries France, Austria and the Netherlands. Whether we want to create more living space in the future in the form of large-scale residential construction and to what extent – this is a discussion we will have to have intensively in the coming years.

The B8 is available in our online store.

Our South Tyrol issue was published in July, in which we looked at new buildings in rural areas and the conversion of historic buildings. Read more here: South Tyrol

Roger Boltshauser: Plea for earth building

Building design
An exhibition on Roger Boltshauser in Stuttgart's Weißenhofsiedlung in March and April shows his exploration of earth building. Sketch: Roger Boltshauser

Roger Boltshauser Response 02.03/23.04.2023, sketch: Roger Boltshauser

An exhibition on Roger Boltshauser opens in Stuttgart’s Weißenhofsiedlung at the beginning of March. His work combines art, design and building as well as a passion for clay as a material.

An exhibition on Roger Boltshauser opens in Stuttgart’s Weißenhofsiedlung at the beginning of March. His work combines art, design and building, as well as a passion for clay as a material.

“If you could eat it, you’d call it superfood.” This is how the organizers whet the appetite for the exhibition on Roger Boltshauser and his clay architecture. It should be sufficiently well known by now that clay is a moisture buffer and fire protection, has a balancing effect on the indoor climate, keeps wooden structures dry, can be found almost everywhere in the world and is easy to work with. And yet we cannot talk enough about this building material and promote it.

An exhibition in Stuttgart does the same and shows the work of Swiss architect Roger Boltshauser, who works a lot with clay construction. For him, it is “a kind of fundamental experience” that still spurs him on today, makes him courageous, but also critical of all conventions and constantly drives him to find new solutions. Boltshauser then became known to a wider circle in 2008 when he and Martin Rauch built the latter’s single-family house from rammed earth in Vorarlberg (Baumeister 7/2009). At the time, it was still said that they were building “at their own risk”, a test building. The realization required ten to twenty times less energy than a conventional concrete or brick building. However, the amount of work involved was very high.

Some clients are now also enthusiastic about earth building, and a few larger earth buildings have already been built – such as the Ricola Herbal Center by Herzog & de Meuron or the Alnatura office building by Haas Cook Zemmrich. Boltshauser is working on a number of promising research projects and is also planning large buildings made of rammed earth. In his opinion, the future belongs to intelligent hybrid constructions. His colleague Martin Rauch is convinced that the next decade will be an era of earth building. It brings a new aspect of responsibility to planning and building – “simply building, putting perfectionism into perspective”, as he puts it(Baumeister 6/2021).

In this respect, one can never make enough pleas for earth building – as the architect will certainly do in his opening speech at the Weißenhofsiedlung in Stuttgart next Wednesday. The exhibition on Boltshauser aims to show that in his work, art, design and construction combine in “constant parallel processes”. Some of his collage sketches will therefore also be on display. Ultimately, it is clear that Roger Boltshauser is concerned at all levels with the search for an authentic answer.

From 2 March to 23 April 2023 at the Architekturgalerie am Weißenhof | Stuttgarter Weißenhofsiedlung, Am Weißenhof 30, Stuttgart | Curated by Roger Boltshauser with Atelier Andrea Gassner | Organized by Kyra Bullert | Exhibition design: Atelier Andrea Gassner | Vernissage: Wednesday, 1 March 2023, 7 pm: Lecture by Roger Boltshauser in the lecture hall Neubau 2

By the way, also in Stuttgart: an eyewear store with panache