Opens in a new tab

Lena Deutmann: “Detective flair is required here”

Building design
Lena Deutmann studied at the Cologne University of Applied Sciences in the field of documents and graduated with a Master's degree. The paper conservator has been working at the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne since 2015. Photo: private

Lena Deutmann studied at the Cologne University of Applied Sciences in the field of documents and graduated with a Master's degree. The paper conservator has been working at the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne since 2015. Photo: private

What motivates Lena Deutmann? The paper conservator is responsible for the “Restoration Documentation Module” at the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne, which was specially developed for the Cologne City Archive and its tasks after the collapse. A portrait of Lena Deutmann is always surrounded by paper, sheets of paper and books. This is not surprising, because the paper conservator’s workplace is the […]

Paper conservator Lena Deutmann is responsible for the “Restoration Documentation Module” at the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne, which was specially developed for the Cologne City Archive and its tasks following the collapse. A portrait

Lena Deutmann is always surrounded by paper, pages and books. This is not surprising, because the paper conservator’s workplace is the restoration center of the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne. But her work involves processes, tables and ticking boxes in the right place in a computer system. This is because Lena Deutmann is responsible for the “Restoration Documentation Module”. The program, called RDM for short, was developed specifically for the Cologne City Archive and its tasks following the collapse together with the Bonn-based company “startext”. The program completely replaces the paper-based documentation in Cologne. This means, for example, that the 45 different versions of the old routing slips had to be brought up to the same standard. Lena Deutmann talks enthusiastically about the perfect documentation of all conditions and work – also in order to be able to provide court-proof data in recourse proceedings.

Finding and working through errors in the system

Her work involves clearing up previous booking errors as well as deciphering some of the hieroglyphic handwriting on the routing slips and finding and working through errors in the system. “You really need a bit of detective flair here. My ability to familiarize myself with existing processes and to keep an eye on previous and subsequent processes comes in very handy when working with ‘legacy issues’,” says Lena Deutmann, who has rarely missed practical restoration work.

Teamwork and exchange

Lena Deutmann has followed the usual training path: Internship at the Dortmund City Archive, pre-study internships at the Central Restoration Workshops of the NRW State Archive in Münster-Coerde and the bookbindery of the Museum of Art and Cultural History (MKK) in Dortmund. She then went on to study at the Cologne University of Applied Sciences in the field of written materials, graduating with a Master’s degree. Afterwards, at the beginning of 2015, she applied for a job at the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne. “I was interested in the position because I got to know and appreciate working in public institutions through my internships and I particularly enjoy the opportunity to work in a team and exchange ideas with restorers, archivists and historians. Working freelance – independently and more or less alone – was never really an option for me,” says Deutmann, who really enjoys being able to work in NRW, where her family lives.

Lena Deutmann enjoys interdisciplinary work

This work includes giving lectures in collaboration with the company “startext” or on behalf of the archive and presenting the work with the documentation module. In future, the paper conservator will no longer have quite so much to do with the development of the RDM. This is because the system is now stable. But there will still be a contact person for questions about the software. And that pleases Lena Deutmann, because: “I enjoy interdisciplinary work, so supporting and assisting in the further development of the RDM will certainly remain part of my remit for some time to come.”

Lena Deutmann studied at the Cologne University of Applied Sciences in the field of written materials and graduated with a Master’s degree. The paper conservator has been working at the Historical Archive of the City of Cologne since 2015.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

HOAI no longer applies – and now?

Building design

Being a columnist is a difficult existence in digital times. Unlike in the past, readers can respond directly via social media. You are well advised to write something that will win the approval of your readers. I fear that this text will fail in this respect. It is about to comment positively on a legal judgment, […]

Being a columnist is a difficult existence in digital times. Unlike in the past, readers can respond directly via social media. You are well advised to write something that will win the approval of your readers.

I fear that this text will fail in this respect. It is about to comment positively on a legal ruling that takes something away from the architects, i.e. you. Namely, a degree of planning security and reliable minimum rates for your own work. You will have noticed – according to the European Court of Justice, the fee structure for architects violates the EU Services Directive. Brussels wants unrestricted market access for all and sees the HOAI as undermining free price competition.

As expected, the profession is critical of the ECJ ruling. The outcry was huge and unanimous. Architect Eike Becker articulated his concerns to us. I understand them. But it must also be said that free markets are a key objective of European policy. Most of us probably approve of this in principle (although the fundamental failure of market mechanisms is often proclaimed, especially in architectural discourse). However, if this declared goal of the EU is generally considered sensible, we should continue to do so as those directly affected.

The basic fear of many architects: The new free pricing opens the door to dumping offers. And one thing is clear: there will be new providers who offer their own services below the previous HOAI minimum rates. This is a challenge – for every architectural firm, but also for professional representatives (chambers, etc.). The challenge now is to promote the quality of one’s own services with renewed vigor. Above all, it is also important to explain one’s own understanding of quality. It is true that up to now, consumer protection and quality assurance have also been pursued via the fee structure. We now need new mechanisms for this. However, contrary to what some prophets of doom would have us believe, this is possible. Incidentally, the purchasers of architectural services, i.e. clients, developers and investors, also have a role to play here. They themselves must (and will) realize that awarding the contract to the cheapest provider does not automatically lead to the best result – not even economically. They need to become more competent. Sorry to have to use this unpopular word again, but this is how the market works.

The president of the Federal Association of Liberal Professions called the ruling “disappointing”. “Cutting quality in favor of price is also a mistake in the construction sector,” he criticized. And he is right about the latter. For me, however, this means above all that it is now up to the entire architectural profession and the construction industry to ensure that this does not happen.

Weißenhofsiedlung Stuttgart

Building design
View of LeCorbusier's semi-detached house with the typical flat roof, columns and long ribbon windows. Photo: Jaimrsilva, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Photo: Jaimrsilva, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In 1927, 17 architects created the Weißenhofsiedlung in Stuttgart as a blueprint for modern architecture. The German Werkbund thus introduced new ideas of modern living to the building exhibition of the time. Everything you need to know about the 33 townhouses, their history, the architects under the direction of Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, the 100th anniversary of this Werkbund Estate and the future IBA’27 can be read here.

The Weißenhofsiedlung set architectural standards

The Weißenhofsiedlung will be 100 years old in 2027. Anyone talking about urban planning and architecture in Stuttgart cannot remain silent about it. And it has been a household name far beyond the borders of Baden-Württemberg and Germany from the moment it was built It was not until the beginning of 2022 that an urban planning ideas competition for the Weißenhofsiedlung Stuttgart, which was looking for forward-looking visions for the listed site, was decided. The key criterion was a development based on the innovative spirit of the historic estate. The concepts from 1927 are still on everyone’s lips today. As part of the building exhibition “Die Wohnung”, the Deutscher Werkbund succeeded in introducing an idea of modern living that turned familiar norms on their head. The result was 33 townhouses. And with them 33 designs for modern, healthy, affordable and functional living. Within just four months, 500,000 people visited the exhibition. The worldwide response was huge. To put it in pathetic terms: a myth was born.

The work of the Deutscher Werkbund

What is regarded as the blueprint for modern architecture is thanks to the Deutscher Werkbund. It was founded in 1907 as an “association of artists, architects, entrepreneurs and experts”. The members wanted to find fundamentally new approaches to design by bringing together aesthetics and industrial production methods. Their work was by no means limited to architecture. Under the motto “from sofa cushions to urban planning”, they developed concepts and designs for all objects of everyday life. In 1927, they explored the question of what the modern form of living could look like in the exhibition “The Dwelling”. Under the direction of Ludwig Mies van der Rohe , 17 representatives from five countries took part in the exhibition. Among them were renowned architects such as Walter Gropius, Hans Scharoun, Bruno and Max Taut and Pierre Jeanneret with Charles Edouard Jeanneret-Gris – better known as Le Corbusier. His “Five points for a new architecture” can be seen as an example in the Weißenhofsiedlung Stuttgart. And caused quite a stir.

Le Corbusier’s visions in the Weissenhof Estate

In a semi-detached house and in the Citrohan House, Le Corbusier realized central features of his understanding of architecture. These include the free floor plan design. The living room can be divided into several bedrooms in just a few simple steps. The construction of reinforced concrete posts and membranes is also essential for this. Thanks to the post system and the use of reinforced concrete, he was able to create long ribbon windows across the entire width of the room instead of conventional high windows. He also established the shape of the flat roof, which is used as a roof garden. His houses are now a UNESCO World Heritage Site. In addition to the flat roof and ribbon windows, the Weißenhofsiedlung created other design paradigms. The architecture is characterized by cubic forms and unadorned minimalism. The interiors were adaptable for different living situations thanks to flexible installations. Sliding walls or sliding beds adapt to different needs. The multi-functionality of the living space extended to the outside area. Spacious terraces were created there for free use. All innovations followed socio-economic premises.

Basic ideas of the Weißenhof Estate

The building constructions are variably combinable, but standardized. The aim was to achieve cost-effective realization. The use of new construction methods and materials such as lightweight concrete, cork panels and dry construction also contributed to the affordability of the residential buildings. The exhibition pursued the basic idea of improving the housing and living conditions of a broad population. With this in mind, the architects involved developed concepts for functional houses and apartments. With plenty of light, air and warmth, but at the same time affordable.

Other architects involved were:

  • Peter Behrens,
  • Victor Bourgeois,
  • Richard Döcker,
  • Josef Frank,
  • Ludwig Hilberseimer,
  • Ferdinand Kramer,
  • Jacobus Johannes Pieter Oud,
  • Hans Poelzig,
  • Adolf Rading,
  • Adolf Gustav Schneck and
  • Mart Stam.

The Stuttgart graphic designer Willi Baumeister was responsible for the exhibition content as typographer. Among other things, he designed the hall lettering and the main poster. He also designed the Werkbund memorandum and the official catalog.

Historical development of the Weissenhof Estate

The successful exhibition was followed by hostility and devaluation of the estate by the National Socialists from 1933 onwards. Defamed as too foreign due to the white roof terraces, the estate was to be demolished. Due to the outbreak of war, this never happened. However, parts of the area were destroyed during air raids on Stuttgart. After the war, there were still isolated demolitions. Other buildings were colored over with gabled roofs. In 1958, the Weißenhofsiedlung was finally placed under a preservation order. The remaining houses were then renovated in the 1980s. At the same time, the State Academy of Fine Arts submitted an exciting proposal. They wanted to use the ensemble of buildings as administration and studio space and create a meeting place. This was rejected by the state. Instead, the buildings were rented out privately. The privatization of the Le Corbusier buildings in particular provoked criticism from the art academy.

IBA’27 – visions of the future and innovative spirit from back then

In 2006, the semi-detached house by Le Corbusier and Pierre Jeanneret was finally converted into a museum and opened to the public. One half of the house shows the reconstructed state of 1927, with the room layout, color scheme and furnishings identical to the original ideal of 1927. The other part of the house houses an exhibition on the history of the entire estate. All other houses are still inhabited. In 2019, the city of Stuttgart acquired the entire ensemble of buildings from the federal government. A new building for IBA’27 will add a new element to the structure at the Academy of Fine Arts. Now the building exhibition is once again posing the question: How do we want to live in the future? To mark its centenary, the IBA is taking a look at the past and the future. There are familiar and completely new challenges that urban planning has to face today. The Weißenhofsiedlung as a place of innovation and inspiration is likely to stimulate discussions at all levels.

The competition for the new building was won by the consortium Schmutz & Partner Freie Architekten Innenarchitekten PartG mbB with Scala Freie Architekten Stadtplaner and Pfrommer + Roeder GbR. Find out what the new reception and visitor center will look like from our colleagues at Garten + Landschaft: Weißenhofsiedlung Stuttgart IBA’27.

You can find out more about LeCorbusier here.