Littmann Collection: Alte Nationalgalerie restitutes paintings

Building design
Lovis Corinth, Eleonore von Wilke, 1907. The painting was restituted by the Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitz to the heirs of Ismar and Käthe Littmann and subsequently donated to the Alte Nationalgalerie, where it remains on public display. Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Nationalgalerie / Photographer: Andres Kilger
Lovis Corinth, Eleonore von Wilke, 1907. The painting was restituted by the Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitz to the heirs of Ismar and Käthe Littmann and subsequently donated to the Alte Nationalgalerie, where it remains on public display. Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Nationalgalerie / Photographer: Andres Kilger

The Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation (SPK) has restituted the painting “Eleonore von Wilke” by Lovis Corinth from the collection Littmann to the heirs of Ismar and Käthe Littmann. The heirs then donated the work to the Alte Nationalgalerie, where it will continue to be on display following the Corinth exhibition. The handover marks an important step in provenance research and the preservation of artworks that fell into foreign hands during the Nazi era as a result of forced sales and persecution.

Ismar Littmann (1878-1934) was a respected German lawyer and notary in Breslau. In the 1920s, Littmann began to build up an extensive art collection that included works by contemporary artists such as Lovis Corinth, Max Pechstein, Erich Heckel, Otto Mueller and Max Liebermann. He financed the acquisition of the artworks mainly through loans, regularly using works of art as collateral for banks. After successful repayment, he received the paintings back and was able to use them freely. Until 1933 – despite the global economic crisis – Littmann was able to service his loans properly.
When the National Socialists came to power, Ismar Littmann’s professional, financial and personal circumstances deteriorated rapidly. As early as April 1933, he had to apply for readmission to the bar association, as his law practice had to be temporarily suspended. Although he was granted a limited license on June 1, 1933, he was no longer able to build on his earlier business successes. At the end of 1933, Littmann attempted suicide, which he survived, but the consequences led to his death on September 23, 1934. After his death, his family fell into financial difficulties. His widow Käthe Littmann and his son Hans were forced to sell large parts of the collection Littmann in order to secure their livelihood. The works that had been used as collateral for loans were sold as a result of the economic hardship.

The painting “Eleonore von Wilke” and its provenance

The portrait “Eleonore von Wilke”, painted in 1907, shows the wife of the lawyer and art writer Dr. Adolf von Wilke, a long-time friend of Lovis Corinth. In older catalogs of works and literature, the painting is listed under the title “Countess Finkh”. The painting belonged to the collection Littmann from 1930 at the latest, as a list from that year shows. There is evidence that it came to the collection directly from Adolf von Wilke. Between 1930 and 1937, it was possible to trace the path of the work in detail: It served as collateral for a loan at Bank E. Heimann in Breslau until at least 1935 and remained unsold in two auctions in 1935. It is documented with certainty that the Silesian Museum of Fine Arts acquired the painting in May 1937 for 1,300 Reichsmarks. Since 1965, the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation has held the work in trust after it was offered to the State of Berlin by a private owner. Only after intensive provenance research was it possible to clarify that the painting was one of the persecution-related losses from the Littmann collection and should therefore be restituted to the heirs.

Significance of the restitution

Marion Ackermann, President of the SPK, emphasized the tedious but rewarding work of provenance research: “This case shows that gaps in provenance can still be closed years later. Every closed case means a noticeable relief for the descendants. I am extremely grateful to the heirs of Ismar and Käthe Littmann for their generous gesture: they have donated the restituted work to the Alte Nationalgalerie.”
Anette Hüsch, Director of the Alte Nationalgalerie, emphasized the significance of the donation: “We are very grateful to the heirs for donating the painting ‘Eleonore von Wilke’ to the Alte Nationalgalerie. Provenance research is a central concern for us, which we make visible in publications, exhibitions and audio guide tracks. The donation after the restitution is of particular importance and is presented in the museum in an appropriately lively way.”

POTREBBE INTERESSARTI ANCHE

Extension and renovation of Brühl town hall

Building design

The extension to the listed town hall in Brühl blends harmoniously into the old town with its clear cubature and sand-colored brick. Photo: Taufik Kenan

With the extension and renovation of the listed town hall in Brühl, the Cologne-based architectural firm JSWD has realized a project for the sensitive handling of historical buildings. Following a design competition in 2017, the building was put into operation in November 2023. The total gross floor area is around 5,200 square meters and, in addition to the town hall extension, includes an integrated city library and the redesign of the adjacent Janshof as a town square.

The challenge was to replace the existing extension from the 1960s and at the same time create a contemporary extension that both does justice to the listed old building and sets new urban accents. While the historic main façade of the town hall is oriented towards the market square, the extension develops its presence in the direction of Steinweg and in particular towards Janshof.

The design picks up on the differentiated urban spaces of Brühl’s old town by linking the three entrance situations – Markt, Steinweg and Janshof – on the first floor. This strategy creates a functional and spatial link between the existing historical buildings and contemporary additions.

The new building reinterprets the cubature of the monument and develops an independent building volume consisting of three interlocking structures. The gabled view of the staggered front building reflects the proportions of the old town and blends harmoniously into the existing urban fabric.

The material-appropriate implementation of the façade design is particularly noteworthy. The sand-colored brick not only gives the building good legibility, but also differentiates functionally between the various areas of use. Large incisions mark the entrances, perforated façades mark the office floors, while filter masonry screens off the library areas. The light-colored brick also consistently clads the roof surfaces, reinforcing the cubic effect of the new building.

The functional structure of the building follows a well thought-out concept that takes into account the different visitor frequencies and opening times. All rooms – from the wedding room to the service center to the multifunctional hall and the library – are arranged in such a way that they can be accessed independently. This flexibility enables both efficient operational management and synergy effects by linking different functions.

The new foyer with its spacious, real wood veneered counter acts as a central point of contact and combines the functions of citizen service and tourist information. A metal mesh curtain allows it to be closed outside operating hours.

The city library is spread over several floors according to theme, taking into account different acoustic requirements and spatial references. The central information desk is located on the second floor, while the children’s library in the basement is characterized by walk-in, colourfully designed built-in furniture and a naturally lit reading courtyard. This differentiated spatial arrangement creates specific atmospheres for different user groups.

The project is characterized by high energy standards, with maximum preservation of the old building fabric. Energy and heat are supplied by a combined heat and power plant. Triple-glazed windows, a high daylight yield, external sun protection and partial concrete activation guarantee reduced energy requirements. These measures demonstrate how contemporary energy efficiency can also be achieved in listed buildings.

The transformation of the former parking lot at Janshof into an attractive urban space is a key component of Brühl’s inner city development. The continuous, barrier-free paving and the reduction to a few design elements create clarity and transparency within the heterogeneous peripheral development.

The concept of “shared space” eliminates the separation between traffic and pedestrians and leads to a significant reduction in driving speeds. The northern side of the square facing the town hall remains car-free and is suitable for outdoor gastronomy, while twenty parking spaces are arranged in the shade of a grove of trees to the south.

The restoration of the Gavnø retable

Building design
By removing the browned varnish, the altar appears again in its full colorfulness. Photo: © the Lübeck Museums

By removing the browned varnish, the altar appears again in its full colorfulness. Photo: © the Lübeck Museums

The St. Annen Museum in Lübeck is presenting the cabinet exhibition “Traces of the Centuries – On the Restoration of the Gavnø Retable” from June 5 to October 3, 2021 The Gavnø retable is one of the great treasures of the St. Annen Museum in Lübeck. The precious three-winged altarpiece was painted by Jacob van Utrecht around 1515 and has now undergone extensive conservation work for more than a year […]

Lübeck’s St. Annen Museum presents the cabinet exhibition “Traces of the Centuries – On the Restoration of the Gavnø Retable” from June 5 to October 3, 2021

The Gavnø retable is one of the great treasures of the St. Annen Museum in Lübeck. The precious three-winged altarpiece was painted by Jacob van Utrecht around 1515 and has now been undergoing extensive conservation and restoration work for more than a year. The name of the Gavnø retable is derived from its long-time location: Gavnø Castle on the island of the same name in Denmark. Here, the triptych was in the collection of the Danish Minister of State Otto Count Thott (1703-1785) and his family until it was auctioned at Christie’s in London in 1976. In 2011, it was acquired by the St. Annen Museum with funds from the estate of Georg Bartsch and with the help of the Kulturstiftung der Länder. The estate was also used to finance the extensive restoration.

During the restoration work, the restorers at Butt repeatedly uncovered evidence of earlier interventions, revealing a long and eventful restoration history of the 16th century panels. Visitors to Lübeck’s St. Annen Museum now have the opportunity to immerse themselves in the restoration history in the cabinet exhibition “Traces of the Centuries – On the Restoration of the Gavnø Retable” and understand the measures and results of the work.

The restoration work, which also includes scientific, technical and artisanal components, represents an exciting starting point for an examination of the altarpiece. For example, the restoration of the old measures makes it possible for the first time to approximate the original appearance of the paintings.

The restoration work

By removing the browned varnish, the altar appears again in its full colorfulness. An underdrawing, which was made visible using an infrared camera, provides new insights into the creation of the retable, which was commissioned by the wealthy Lübeck merchant Hermann Plönnies and his wife Ida. Both are immortalized on the side panels of the triptych, whose central panel shows the Annunciation to Mary.

Microscope images were used to magnify details such as tool marks, craquelure and chipping. Examinations with UV light made retouching, older overpaintings and varnishes visible. And tiny samples from the paint layer provided information about the pigments and binders used as well as the thickness of various layers of paint and varnish.

The Gavnø retable – highlight of the collection

Museum director Dr. Dagmar Täube is delighted: “It is great to be able to present another highlight of the collection, freshly restored, and thus once again highlight the great value of the St. Annen Museum’s collection. Not only the painterly quality of Jacob van Utrecht can now be seen again, but also narrative details such as the stork on the building, the church towers in the background or the swans on the lake are finally recognizable again.

The exhibition can be seen in the St. Annen Museum up to and including October 3. You can get a first insight into the exhibition in the following video: