Opens in a new tab

Municipal land policy and climate – How property blocks sustainability

Who actually owns the city? And why do local authorities find it so difficult to use their land in a climate-friendly way? The answer does not lie in a lack of will or a lack of concepts, but in ownership itself – a bulwark against sustainable urban development. If you want truly climate-friendly cities, you have to tackle municipal land policy. Because property is the new bottleneck of sustainability.

  • Analysis of the central role of land policy for climate protection and sustainable urban development.
  • Critical examination of historical developments in land law and ownership in Germany, Austria and Switzerland.
  • Explanation of how private ownership and speculative land utilization slow down sustainability.
  • Detailed examples from local authorities: options for action, obstacles and innovative approaches.
  • Deepening the interactions between land policy, climate resilience and social urban development.
  • Legal, economic and social barriers to a climate-oriented land policy.
  • Discussion about reforms: Leaseholds, pre-emption rights, land funds and new alliances.
  • Evaluation of international models and their transferability to German-speaking countries.
  • Conclusion: Why sustainable urban development needs a paradigm shift in dealing with property.

Property as a straitjacket – How land policy is blocking the climate

Anyone walking through German cities today can see this at first glance: Urban space is characterized by ownership. For decades, land has been privatized, parceled out, sold and inherited. This process has evolved historically and is deeply rooted in the bourgeois self-image. But this is precisely where the dilemma of sustainable urban development begins. This is because property is not neutral – it is an instrument of power that fundamentally limits access to land, its use and thus also its development opportunities. Local authorities experience every day how their planning options are frustrated by the limits of ownership.

The German Basic Law guarantees property and protects it to a special degree. However, what was intended as protection against arbitrariness and state encroachment is now often blocking cities’ ability to adapt to new challenges. Climate change, heat waves, heavy rainfall, land consumption – all of these require a flexible, forward-looking land policy geared towards the common good. However, the majority of urban land has long been in private hands. As a result, local authorities can often only buy back land for parks, fresh air corridors, retention areas or sustainable housing at a high price – if at all. Speculative price increases and confusing ownership structures do the rest.

Land is not a resource that can be increased at will. On the contrary: its scarcity and its central role in climate protection make it a key strategic resource of the 21st century. But while almost all other climate policy issues – from energy and mobility to the circular economy – have long since become central fields of action, land policy has been relegated to a niche existence. This is not due to a lack of interest on the part of local authorities, but to the property system itself. Every rezoning, every change of use, every land swap thus becomes a small-scale negotiation thriller. The most powerful weapon against sustainable urban development is not a lack of political will, but private ownership of land.

At the same time, it is clear that where local authorities still have significant areas of land at their disposal, they can take a climate-oriented and socially responsible approach. From Munich to Vienna, from Freiburg to Zurich – innovative districts, green corridors, sponge city concepts and affordable housing are being created wherever municipal land is involved. But this is the exception, not the rule. Historical mistakes – such as the mass sale of municipal land in the 1990s and 2000s – are now taking bitter revenge. Municipal land policy has therefore become a question of fate for the climate-friendly city.

The key insight: property is not a natural right, but a social construction – and can therefore be shaped. Leaving the land market to the forces of supply and demand alone risks the ability of cities to control it. Municipalities need new instruments, the courage to reclaim land and, above all, a radically different understanding of property: as an obligation to the common good and climate justice.

Land law, speculation and climate targets – a toxic triangle

The historical development of land policy in German-speaking countries is a story of missed opportunities. The land issue was already being debated in the German Empire, the Weimar Republic discussed expropriation in favor of housing construction, and land reform was also a key issue after the Second World War. However, private ownership always triumphed over public welfare-oriented approaches. With the liberalization of the markets and the globalization of the real estate sector since the 1990s, this imbalance has worsened. Land has become a commodity, a speculative asset, an object of investment.

This development has had a fatal impact, especially in an urban context. Land prices are rising faster than any increase in construction costs, and private owners’ expectations of returns collide with the need for affordable housing, social infrastructure and green spaces. Local authorities are caught in a vicious circle: they have to spend ever higher sums to buy back land, which in turn drives the price of land even higher. The market does not regulate anything here – it produces scarcity, exclusion and social division.

The climate targets set by the federal, state and local governments are ambitious. But they will remain a waste of time as long as land policy does not follow suit. If you want sponge city strategies, heat-resilient neighborhoods, urban agriculture or large-scale unsealing, you need land. And land that the municipality actually has access to. Private owners, however, have no interest in short-term returns from public use. Their logic is to increase value, not the common good. Climate resilience thus becomes a bargaining chip – or falls by the wayside entirely.

Legally, the municipalities are subject to strict limits. The German Building Code does offer instruments such as the right of first refusal, urban development contracts and the reallocation paragraph. However, these tools are often toothless: they are only effective if certain narrow conditions are met, are delayed by legal proceedings or are weakened by lobbying interests at federal level. Particularly in booming regions, owners pay dearly for their consent or block projects for years. As a result, climate policy gets bogged down in the thicket of land law.

Added to this is the internationalization of the markets. More and more land is in the portfolios of institutional investors, global investment funds or anonymous special purpose vehicles. This makes it almost impossible for local authorities to establish any contact at all with the owners – let alone manage them strategically. The land market has become decoupled from urban society. The question of power is therefore: who owns the city – and who decides on its future?

Innovative approaches: Municipal scope for action and its limits

Despite all the obstacles, there are impressive lighthouse projects that show how municipal land policy can work differently and better. The city of Munich, for example, has been pursuing a consistent land reservation policy for years: wherever possible, the local authority buys land in order to develop it according to criteria that are oriented towards the common good. The instrument of heritable building rights prevents strategic land from disappearing permanently from public ownership. In this way, affordable housing, social infrastructure and climate-adapted open spaces are created – permanently.

Another example is provided by the City of Vienna. Here, the municipal land fund is actively used to secure land for social and ecological projects. The land is not allocated to the highest bidder, but according to clear quality criteria. The result: urban districts are created with a high mix of residents, generous green spaces and innovative mobility concepts. At the same time, speculation and price increases are specifically curbed. Vienna is not considered a role model for many German cities for nothing.

However, smaller cities and municipalities are also increasingly developing creative strategies. In Tübingen, for example, the concept of concept allocation is used: plots are not sold according to the highest bid, but according to the quality of the submitted usage concepts. Criteria such as climate protection, social mix or public welfare-oriented sponsorship are at the forefront. The result is districts that are geared towards the needs of urban society – and not towards the profit interests of investors.

All these approaches show that Municipal land policy can be a key to sustainable, climate-oriented urban development. However, it quickly comes up against legal and financial limits. Local authorities’ resources are limited and market dynamics are overpowering. Without a far-reaching reform of land law and without support from the federal and state governments, these lighthouse projects will remain the exception. The land market is not a normal market segment – it is the nerve center of urban transformation.

Above all, however, we need a paradigm shift in the way we deal with property. Only if the common good is given priority over individual profit interests can cities become climate-friendly, socially just and sustainable. This requires courage – and a new self-image of municipal planning.

Ways out of the ownership trap: reforms, alliances and international perspectives

Overcoming the property blockade requires more than just local initiatives. What is needed is a package of measures that systematically expands the municipalities’ scope for action. First and foremost is the reform of land law. The municipal right of first refusal must be strengthened, streamlined and made less bureaucratic. The introduction of a land fund geared towards the common good at state or federal level could also enable local authorities to strategically secure land – independently of short-term budgetary constraints. The idea is that society, not the market, decides how land is used.

Another lever lies in the expansion of heritable building rights. It prevents valuable land from permanently ending up in private hands and secures the municipality’s control in the long term. However, this requires a change in mentality – not only among investors, but also in administration and among political decision-makers. The narrative of “good ownership” must be replaced by the model of “responsible ownership”.

In some cases, alliances with civil society actors, housing cooperatives and local initiatives can help to remove land from speculation. Models such as the Mietshäuser Syndikat or foundation structures create new forms of ownership that are committed to the common good. Networking with international pioneers is also an important source of inspiration. Cities such as Zurich, Copenhagen and Amsterdam show how consistent land policy enables sustainable urban development.

At the same time, the federal and state governments must strengthen local authorities financially and legally. Funding programs, guarantees and targeted tax incentives can facilitate the reclamation of land and accelerate the implementation of climate-oriented projects. Digitalization offers additional opportunities: digital land registry systems, data-supported land analysis and transparent award procedures can speed up processes and prevent abuse.

Ultimately, the land issue is a social issue. What kind of city do we want? Who should have a say? And how much of the common good are we prepared to price into property rights? The transformation to a sustainable city is not a technocratic process – it is a political tour de force. Anyone who wants to save the climate must have the courage to tackle the very foundations of property ownership. This is the only way to dissolve the silent blockades that are currently preventing any real innovation in many places.

Conclusion: No climate-friendly city without a new land policy

Municipal land policy is the underestimated lever in sustainable urban development. While technologies, energy and mobility receive a lot of attention, land remains the silent bottleneck. In many places, private ownership of land is blocking the necessary adaptations to climate change, social challenges and new living models. The examples from Munich, Vienna and Tübingen show this: Where local authorities retain control, innovative, climate-resilient and socially just districts are created. But this remains the great exception.

The only way to a climate-friendly city is through a radical reassessment of property. Land is not a commodity, but the basis for social participation and ecological resilience. Anyone who wants sustainable urban development must have the courage to rethink property itself – as an obligation, not a privilege. This requires a reform of land law, courageous municipalities, strong alliances and the political will to put the common good above short-term profit interests.

The challenges are great, the resistance powerful. But the alternatives are far more expensive: urban sprawl, social division, climatic tipping points. The time for niche solutions is over. A new, socio-ecological land policy is needed – as the foundation for the city of the future. Only then can urban space once again become what it should be: a common good for all, open to change and ready for the climate of tomorrow.

Also interesting
In London, drivers lose an average of 156 hours a year in traffic - that's 6.5 days. Image source: Unsplash
Global Traffic Scorecard: London remains the city with the most traffic jams
Public spaces in metropolitan areas
white-brown-building-interior-8WTeqNRetes
Linoleum flooring: Sustainable, stylish, future-oriented design
View of Hamburg's HafenCity as an example of urban resilience and systematic urban development.
Resilience Inventory for Cities – How to Systematically Assess Vulnerability
A laptop with spreadsheets and graphs, symbolizing automated planning processes that do not dehumanize people.
How Planning Processes Can Be Automated Without Losing Their Human Touch
bird's-eye-view-photo-of-city-buildings-xaXkWW312w0
Urban Climate Modeling Using Neural Networks
Tegel Airport Lake – a development concept
KfW Head Office in Frankfurt (Photo: KfW Picture Archive / Thorsten Futh)
KfW funding exhausted after just a few hours
Undiscovered apple country
The forest of speech bubbles in the exhibition "Bijou oder Bausünde?" at the Swiss Heritage Center in Zurich shows opinions and debates on how to deal with building culture. Photo Noah Santer/Swiss Heritage Center
Bijou or building sin?

Iridescent roadway

Vincent van Gogh as inspiration: Dutch designer Daan Roosegaarde created a luminous cycle path.

At last, you can cycle through the countryside in Nuenen at night without worrying. The design for a new cycle path by Dutch designer Daan Roosegaardes makes it possible: a luminous path with a swirling pattern that references the night scene in Vincent van Gogh’s painting “The Starry Night”.

Nuenen is located in the Dutch province of Noord-Barbant – east of Eindhoven – where the artist Van Gogh was born and grew up. His first masterpiece “The Potato Eaters”, as well as the painted water mills of Opwettense and Colse, were created in the area. Now the newly created cycle path is intended to create a link between these two mills and boost tourism in Barbant with the help of contemporary design.

A special feature of this project is the surface of the roadway: coated with a special paint that collects solar energy during the day and emits the luminosity again after dark. Together with the company “Heijmans Infrastructure”, Roosegaarde is developing these sparkling stones, which glow for up to eight hours.

If the coated surface cannot charge sufficiently in cloudy weather, additional LEDs along certain bends provide the necessary illumination. A nearby solar system provides the power supply.

Another of the designer’s concepts is the “Glowing Lines” pilot project – a road designed to make driving in the dark easier thanks to integrated light strips.

This article is a collaboration with our sister magazine Garten + Landschaft.

Everything about the 2019 garden show year

The first garden shows of 2019 opened their doors just in time for the spring-like Easter weekend. In addition to the Federal Garden Show in Heilbronn, this year there were also state garden shows in Baden-Württemberg, Bavaria, Brandenburg, Saxony and Upper Austria.

Heilbronn used the BUGA event (April 17 to October 6, 2019) to renew itself from the inside out on a 40-hectare area in the immediate vicinity of the train station. Situated on an island between the Neckar Canal and the Altneckar, the isolated site had been used as an industrial and commercial location and freight station for over 100 years and had long disappeared from the consciousness of the people of Heilbronn. Following the relocation of a section of the B39 federal highway and the extensive removal of explosives and contaminated sites, the future Neckarbogen district will eventually provide living space for 3,500 people and 1,000 jobs in the coming years. The first three completed building plots were already integrated into the garden show as an “urban exhibition”.

In order to create a sustainable living space worth living in for the people of Heilbronn, the city took a new approach to neighborhood development (read the article by Thomas Armonat in G+L 4/2019). A colourful and diverse mix of usage concepts, buildings and residents, along with reduced car traffic, short distances and a modern energy supply, should make the neighbourhoods flexible for future adaptations to changing living conditions.

Pictures: Federal Garden Show Heilbronn 2019 GmbH

Garden shows 2019: experiencing nature in the middle of the city

The concept of the Berlin landscape architects from sinai played a key role in the quality of life of the Neckarbogen. They created four landscape ribbons from the existing patchwork of landscapes. As a result, visitors pass urban cores at the raft harbor with nine-storey buildings and within 15 minutes find themselves at Karlssee lake, which has been landscaped with reed zones. This also serves as a retention basin and filter for rainwater from the neighborhood.

At the same time, a spectacular landscape structure was created towards the Neckar canal. Since then, a cliff up to twelve meters high has shielded noise from the industrial Neckar Canal. Towards the garden show grounds, the shotcrete surface, which is reminiscent of the rocky edges of the surrounding countryside, conceals a vertical playground with climbing and sliding facilities. Gabions filled with local natural stone also border the sides as a compensatory measure for the habitats of lizards and other animals. With the new riverbank design and a 600-metre-long wooden footbridge in the Neckaruferpark, the landscape architects are not only bringing the river back into people’s consciousness, but also enabling them to experience nature in an impressive way – right in the middle of the city!

You can read a detailed article on the BUGA Heilbronn concept in G+L 7/2019.

The concept for the Brandenburg State Garden Show in Wittstock an der Dosse (April 18 to October 6, 2019) also comes from sinai. The town of 15,000 inhabitants is located in the Prignitz region between the Elbe and Müritz rivers. In the south, the 13.5-hectare garden show grounds form a semicircle around the historic brick ring wall of the well-preserved medieval town. To the west of the city wall, the River Glinze flows through the listed Friedrich Ebert Park dating from 1925 with its old trees. To the east, a newly designed and ecologically improved oxbow of the Dosse – the Dossebogen – borders the park on the Bleichwall, which begins at the foot of the former Bischofsburg. There, between an existing row of lime trees with an accompanying promenade and the city wall as a historical backdrop, the landscape architects staged an open meadow space. The “Bleichgärten”, meanwhile, are based on the former commons and, as citizens’ gardens, invite communal appropriation.

Pictures: State Garden Show Wittstock/Dosse 2019

Frankenberg in Saxony is just ten minutes from Chemnitz. Dresden can be reached in half an hour, Leipzig in three quarters of an hour. The attractive location for commuters is a welcome ray of hope in the structural change for the once industrial community of 16,000 inhabitants. As part of the Saxon State Garden Show in Frankenberg, Berlin-based landscape architects Weidinger Landschaftsarchitekten designed two differently characterized parts of the site: a six-hectare, robust leisure park on the Zschopau floodplain to the west of the town center and the landscaped, almost five-hectare valley along the meandering Mühlbach stream to the east.

The heart of the park on the Zschopau is the so-called Zeit-Werk-Stadt, an experience museum for urban and industrial history. To the north of it, a bridge by Sauerzapfe Architekten known as the “snake” spans the B 169 federal road and the Zschopau for pedestrians and cyclists and now connects higher-level cycle paths. Visitors can reach the valley, which the Mühlbach stream has cut around 15 to 20 meters deep, via the town center. The city has added flood protection and ecological water restoration to the wild and romantic atmosphere there. Thanks to a new pedestrian underpass and newly laid out footpaths and cycle paths, many people will in future pass through the Mühlgraben located above the park, which the landscape architects have restored to its historical course as an open channel.

In Baden-Württemberg, 16 municipalities in the Rems Valley, east of Stuttgart, have joined forces to create an atypical state garden show: from the source of the Rems in Essingen via Schwäbisch Gmünd, Schorndorf and Waiblingen to the mouth of the river Neckar near Remseck. They are all located in the Rems Landscape Park, for which the Planstatt Senner office from Überlingen originally worked together with the municipalities on the topics of tourism, cultural landscape and settlement areas. The focus was on improving the quality of life along the river and closing the gaps in the accompanying cycle path network. The good cooperation between the municipalities subsequently led to the idea of hosting a joint Remstal Garden Show in 2019 (May 10 to October 20, 2019).

In addition to the “16 Stations” architectural project, for which each municipality developed a landmark, Schorndorf and Schwäbisch Gmünd – where a state garden show was held as recently as 2014 – also hosted adventure gardens that were open to the public. In Schorndorf, for example, the Munich-based firm Lohrer.Hochrein gave the castle park and the town park a contemporary look. They presented the castle on an open lawn. Meanwhile, a square with water fountains rising from the ground was created at the intersection of the path axes. In the city park, on the other hand, densely planted edges and entrances carved out of them now define the space traversed by a circular path. Flattened bank areas towards the lake even allow visitors to lie down on the grass by the water.

Instead of a large-scale garden show like the one in Rems Valley, the Bavarian municipality of Wassertrüdingen, located halfway between Nuremberg and Ulm, organized a so-called Small State Garden Show (24 May to 8 September 2019). The Berlin-based Planorama office designed two landscaped parks on 13 hectares: the Wörnitzpark to the south of the town center and the Klingenweiherpark to the north. Both are also connected by a path through the city center. Between the Baudenhardt recreation area in the north of the city and the Oettinger Forst forest in the south, a green belt now also extends the urban area. This has also created ecological retreats and recreational areas for residents in the floodplain landscape of the Wörnitz.

Along the Klingenweiher ponds in the north, the landscape architects also added footbridges, pathways and vantage points to the area, known as the Weihersteig. Another architectural highlight is a golden platform that juts out into the water. The hill of a former landfill site has also been turned into a viewing point. To the south, the Wörnitzpark links the town center to the adjacent floodplain landscape. Seating steps border the Mühlweiher pond not far from the old town wall. A gap in the wall at the Entengraben is now closed by a metal lattice construction as a reminder.

Close to the Czech border, the Upper Austrian municipality of Aigen-Schlägl in the Mühlviertel region hosted a regional garden show (May 17 to October 13, 2019), which was dedicated firstly to the themes of conscious living and secondly to the use of resources. For the garden show, the municipality also cooperated with the Schlägl Premonstratensian Abbey, which has been in existence for 800 years, and the Schlägl Organic School, both of which are located on the 15-hectare site. The concept – a circular path linking the gardens and fields of the organic school, the new garden and leisure area for the town and the monastery along with the brewery and the founder’s garden – was also created by the Berlin office ST raum a.

A good fit for the organic cycle, which on the one hand explains to visitors how organic food gets onto their plates and on the other hand addresses how we want to design gardens and agriculture in the future. One of the biggest lasting attractions for Schlägl residents will be the newly created “Aigen-Schlägler Terraces”. There are not only new picnic and barbecue areas for residents, but also community gardens. In addition, the gardens in the Sacred Grove are intended to bring visitors closer to the themes of Christianity, peace and finding oneself. Narrow side paths branch off from the circular route, allowing visitors to discover small, enchanted or special places.

Do you remember the garden shows three years ago? If not, you can also find a review of the 2016 shows here.