Paul Clemen: Pioneer of art and monument conservation in the Rhineland

Building design
Paul Clemen (1866-1947), German art historian and first provincial conservator of the Rhine Province, pioneer of the systematic research and conservation of works of art and buildings. Photo: Dorothea Bleibtreu, Bonn, LVR Office for the Preservation of Monuments, CC BY-SA 2.5, via: Wikimedia Commons
Paul Clemen (1866-1947), German art historian and first provincial conservator of the Rhine Province, pioneer of the systematic research and conservation of works of art and buildings. Photo: Dorothea Bleibtreu, Bonn, LVR Office for the Preservation of Monuments, CC BY-SA 2.5, via: Wikimedia Commons

Paul Clemen had a lasting impact on the perception of works of art and buildings in the Rhineland. As the first provincial conservator of the Rhine Province, he laid the foundation for the systematic recording and preservation of art monuments. His extensive scientific work made Paul Clemen a central figure in German art history and monument conservation.

Paul Clemen was born on October 31, 1866 in Sommerfeld near Leipzig as the son of the Protestant pastor August Clemen. He studied art history, German philology and history in Leipzig, Bonn and Strasbourg, where he received his doctorate in 1889 with a dissertation on the portraits of Charlemagne. He recognized the importance of methodical preservation of historical buildings and art objects early on. His dissertation exemplifies his interest in combining historical research and artistic documentation. As the later Provincial Conservator of the Rhine Province, Paul Clemen developed a scientifically sound approach to the preservation of monuments that continues to set standards in the Rhineland today.

Historical development and work

The institutionalized preservation of monuments in late 19th century Germany formed the framework for Clemen’s work. In 1890 he was commissioned by the Commission for Monument Statistics to inventory the art monuments of the Rhine Province; in 1893 he was appointed the first provincial conservator of the Rhine Province. Under his responsibility, the volumes Die Kunstdenkmäler der Rheinprovinz (The Art Monuments of the Rhine Province) were produced, of which a total of 56 volumes were available by 1937. Together with his colleagues, he documented not only outstanding buildings such as Cologne Cathedral, but also numerous parish churches, Romanesque buildings and medieval wall paintings. His work combined meticulous source research, precise inventory and vivid presentation, setting new standards for the scientific inventory of monuments.

Methodology and scientific approach

Clemens’ working method was characterized by precision and systematic documentation. He combined archive research, graphic recording and photographic documentation in order to record the historical condition of the monuments as accurately as possible. He took a broad view of monuments, which also included townscapes, landscapes as well as industrial and garden monuments. At the same time, he took a critical stance towards reconstructions and advocated the preservation of the original substance. As a professor at the University of Bonn and teacher at the Düsseldorf Art Academy, he contributed to anchoring these methodological standards in the training and practice of monument conservation.

Reception and lasting impact

Paul Clemens’ work was already recognized during his lifetime as a fundamental contribution to the preservation of monuments in the Rhineland. His inventories are still considered a standard reference today and are used intensively by historians, restorers and architects. Institutions such as the Landschaftsverband Rheinland and the Rheinische Verein für Denkmalpflege und Landschaftsschutz (Rhineland Association for the Preservation of Monuments and Landscape Conservation) are explicitly linked to his commitment and his concept of a comprehensive concept of monuments. During the First World War, Clemen also made a name for himself as an organizer of art conservation by campaigning for the recording and preservation of cultural assets in the theaters of war. In his programmatic speech “Rheinische Baudenkmäler und ihr Schicksal – Ein Aufruf an die Rheinländer” (Rhenish architectural monuments and their fate – an appeal to the Rhinelanders) from 1946, he once again emphatically emphasized society’s responsibility for its architectural and artistic monuments.

Paul Clemen’s legacy

Today, Paul Clemen’s name is inextricably linked with the systematic research and preservation of art and architectural monuments in the Rhineland. His inventories, writings and methodological standards form an essential foundation of modern monument preservation in Germany. Clemen showed that historic buildings must not only be restored, but also understood and communicated as living testimonies of cultural identity. Through his combination of scientific accuracy, organizational skills and public communication, he became a formative role model for several generations of monument conservators.

POTREBBE INTERESSARTI ANCHE

The splendor of antique metal vessels

Building design
around 400 BC.

around 400 BC.

The new special exhibition “Shimmering Jars of Ore” by the State Collections of Antiquities and Glyptothek Munich, in cooperation with the Bavarian Palace Administration, shows ancient vessels made of bronze and silver in the Pompejanum in Aschaffenburg. Hagen Schaaff, metal conservator at the Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek München, gives an insight into his work before the exhibition opens On May 30, the annual special exhibition […]

The new special exhibition “Shimmering Jars of Ore” at the State Collections of Antiquities and Glyptothek in Munich, in cooperation with the Bavarian Palace Administration, is showing ancient vessels made of bronze and silver in the Pompejanum in Aschaffenburg. Hagen Schaaff, metal conservator at the Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek München, gives an insight into his work before the exhibition begins


Bronzeklylix, um 400 v. Chr., griechisch: Für die Sonderausstellung wurden die antiken Oberflächen der einzelnen Bestandteile der Schale freigelegt sowie die beiden gegossenen Henkel und der gegossene Ringfuß wieder angesetzt. Foto: Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek München
Bronze klylix, around 400 BC, Greek: For the special exhibition, the ancient surfaces of the individual components of the bowl were uncovered and the two cast handles and the cast ring base were reattached. Photo: State Collections of Antiquities and Glyptothek Munich

On May 30, the annual special exhibition of the Staatliche Antikensammlung und Glyptothek München opened at the Pompejanum in Aschaffenburg. The show was originally scheduled to be presented at the end of March. So we are all the more delighted that visitors can now visit the “Shimmering Jars of Ore” exhibition. Until the end of October, the special exhibition shows the different functions, the diversity and the timeless design of ancient bronze vessels from the Greco-Roman, Achaemenid and Etruscan cultures from the 8th century B.C. to the 3rd century A.D. It also illustrates how magnificently these ancient metal vessels were designed and the technical mastery with which they were crafted.

When we think of ancient utilitarian vessels, but also the table luxury of the Greeks, Etruscans and Romans, our thoughts first wander to painted clay vases. However, the wealthy society of the time used “shimmering jugs of ore” for religious occasions, elegant banquets and also for fetching water. These often bore figurative decoration, carved or in relief. As early as the late Neolithic period, the early toreuts – craftsmen specializing in metal – worked metal vessels from natural deposits of solid gold, silver or copper. With the invention of bronze, an alloy of copper and tin, a rapid technological development began in the 4th millennium BC: The melting point of the material decreased considerably, but the end product was harder than the two starting materials. The development of bronze as a material probably began in the Near East. In ancient times, gleaming metal vessels made of gold-colored bronze were a sign of prosperity that anyone could achieve. Luxury vessels made of bronze and gold, on the other hand, could only be afforded by a very small elite group. Over time, bronze vessels became coveted prestige objects that were traded over long distances. Greek and Etruscan toreuts supplied the entire Mediterranean region with their products. When the Romans conquered and plundered Greece, ancient Greek bronze vessels were so coveted that even the tombs of the great necropolises were ransacked to meet demand. While the ancient bronzes are covered in a green or brown patina after centuries or millennia of storage in the ground, the ancient toreutens aimed for a fresh, metallic sheen. Accordingly, the pieces were regularly cleaned and freed from signs of ageing during their period of use. The shimmering sheen was an essential part of the effect of such valuable objects.

Today, the antique bronze objects exhibit very different surface conditions. “However, almost all of the vessels on display are currently in a good condition in terms of conservation and restoration, so that only a few measures had to be carried out in the course of preparing for the exhibition, apart from the plinths,” explains Hagen Schaaff, metal conservator at the Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek Munich. The reason for the different surface condition is the naturally altered state of preservation of the bronzes due to corrosion. The color images and states of preservation are based on the different copper compounds that have formed after the reaction of the metal with the ambient atmosphere of the respective place of discovery. A distinction is made here between marine finds, soil finds and freely weathered bronzes. The surface appearance of the vessels is also influenced by historical and current restoration and conservation measures. Many of the objects on display in the Pompejanum were cleaned electrolytically and chemically in the 1970s. This process usually results in a bright, scarred metallic surface. However, wet-chemical processes and reduction processes destroy the patina and are almost completely ruled out today due to their uncontrollable use. The annealing of bronzes, which was practiced until the beginning of the 20th century, is also no longer used, as this also destroys surfaces. “Today,” says Hagen Schaaff, “restoration work is generally only carried out mechanically. Not only scalpels and scraping tools are used for this, but also special equipment from dental technology and precision mechanics such as ultrasonic devices and ultra-fine pressure blasting equipment.”

For the special exhibition in the Pompejanum, for example, the antique surface of the individual components of the Greek brozeklylix from around 400 BC was uncovered and the two cast handles and the cast ring base were reattached. Following restoration, the embossed bronze bowl now has a blue-green patina. In antiquity, the body of the bowl was decorated with concentric circles inside and out on the lathe. Ornaments such as a central rosette, tongue patterns and palmettes were engraved by hand on the inside. The unrestored condition of the surface of the Greek statuette of a cow from the end of the 6th century BC is very good. After the restoration for the special exhibition, the surface of the front now appears reddish dark brown. Three handles of a bronze hydria, 2nd half of the 6th century BC, from the collection of James Loeb show a special feature, with attachments in the form of ivy leaves. Mineralized fabric remains are preserved on two of the attachments. These are traces of the fabric in which the water vessel was wrapped for protection. It was probably used as a secondary cinerary urn in a grave.

The special exhibition “Shimmering Jars of Ore” can be seen at the Pompejanum in Aschaffenburg until the end of October.

Read more in the current issue of RESTAURO 6/20.

Right down to the last corner

Building design

with which you can also get into hard-to-reach places. Photo:© Arbortech Europa GmbH

When renovating a bathroom, there are often those awkward places that are difficult to reach and work on. Tiles in corners or tight spaces under the washbasin, for example. Arbotech aims to counteract this problem with the development of the Mini Grinder Trade angle grinder: Advertorial Article Parallax Article

When renovating a bathroom, there are often those awkward places that are difficult to reach and work on. Tiles in corners or tight spaces under the washbasin, for example. With the development of the Mini Grinder Trade angle grinder, Arbotech aims to counteract this problem : (more…)