Opens in a new tab

The future of urban land use planning – resilience as a statutory standard?

Building design
Construction helmet on a work surface with site manager in the background as a symbol of resilient urban planning and urban land use planning of the future.

How cities are anchoring resilience as a binding benchmark in planning

Resilience as the new gold standard for urban development? The future of urban land use planning is facing a revolution: what was previously considered a voluntary bonus could soon become a legal requirement. Between the climate crisis, urbanization and growing complexity, experts are calling for resilience to no longer be the exception, but a binding planning standard. Anyone who hesitates now runs the risk of missing out on the coming challenges of urban development.

  • Definition and importance of resilience in urban land use planning
  • Legal foundations and current developments in German, Austrian and Swiss planning law
  • Practical examples: How resilient is planning today?
  • Technological innovations and data integration as a driver for resilient planning
  • Risks and opportunities of enshrining resilience in law
  • Recommendations for planners and local authorities: what needs to be done now
  • Stakeholders, governance and social acceptance
  • Outlook: The resilient city as a new guiding principle for urban land use planning

Resilience – from buzzword to the foundation of urban land use planning

Anyone dealing with urban land use planning today can no longer avoid the term “resilience”. The term originally comes from psychology and describes the ability of a system to recover from disruptions. In urban and landscape planning, resilience has long since established itself as a key concept that goes far beyond pure disaster prevention. It refers not only to the ability to react to extreme events such as floods or heatwaves, but rather to proactive resilience: cities and neighborhoods should be designed in such a way that they can react flexibly to changes and disruptions – be they climatic, social or economic challenges.

However, in urban land-use planning, i.e. the binding control of structural and landscape development through land-use and development plans, resilience has so far often been treated in passing. Nature conservation, climate adaptation, risk prevention – all of this can be found in the relevant laws and guidelines. But a clear, legally binding obligation for resilient planning has so far been sought in vain. This is currently changing: pressure is growing to enshrine resilience in law as a new foundation of spatial planning. After all, the climate crisis knows no compromises and does not wait for voluntary pioneers.

Experts are therefore calling for resilience to no longer be a “nice to have” in guiding principles and model projects, but to be included as a binding criterion in the building code and state building regulations. This would mean Every plan, every new neighborhood, every change of use must demonstrate how it deals with future risks – and not just in the environmental report, but as a central decision-making criterion. Resilience could thus become the benchmark against which the quality and sustainability of urban land-use plans must be measured.

But what exactly does this mean in practice? How can resilience be made measurable? And how can it be formulated in a legally compliant manner without freezing into rubber paragraphs or bureaucracy? The answers to these questions are as diverse as the challenges facing cities today. But one thing is clear: anyone who defines resilience as a standard must rethink planning – from methodology to participation to implementation.

This is not just about technocratic control, but about a changed understanding of the roles of all stakeholders: planners, administrations, investors and civil society must learn to see uncertainty as an opportunity. Resilient urban land use planning requires the courage to experiment, openness to new data sources and the willingness to question traditional routines. Only in this way can the city of tomorrow not only survive, but thrive – despite all crises.

Legal perspectives: Will resilience become a binding standard?

A look at the law books shows: Urban land-use planning in Germany, Austria and Switzerland is a complex web of federal regulations, EU directives and municipal bylaws. The German Building Code (BauGB) regulates the basic principles, but leaves plenty of scope for local adaptations. So far, it has mainly contained references to environmental precautions, climate protection and sustainable development. Resilience only appears implicitly, if at all – for example in the risk analysis or the consideration of flood hazards.

In recent years, however, political and social expectations have shifted. The amendment of the Climate Adaptation Act, the EU directive on the resilience of critical infrastructures and the recommendations of the German Academy for Urban and Regional Planning (DASL) make it clear that legislators are under pressure to act. The first federal states have already begun to explicitly integrate resilience into their state building codes and climate adaptation concepts. In Baden-Württemberg, for example, local authorities have had to submit a “risk and resilience assessment” for every plan since 2023 – a novelty that could set a precedent nationwide.

The signals are also clear at European level. In its Urban Agenda and Green Deal, the EU demands that cities not only become CO₂-neutral, but also climate and socially resilient. Funding is increasingly linked to proof of resilience strategies. This is fundamentally changing the framework conditions for urban land use planning: what used to be considered visionary is now becoming a mandatory task.

But how can resilience be operationalized with legal certainty? Experts discuss various approaches: From clear indicators and test criteria to mandatory scenario analyses and new participation formats that involve those affected at an early stage. One thing is clear: resilience must be concrete, verifiable and justiciable – otherwise it will remain a toothless tiger. This requires new interfaces between planning, environmental law, disaster prevention and digitalization.

Planners and administrations are therefore well advised to deal with the upcoming requirements at an early stage. Those who invest now in further training, data management and interdisciplinary cooperation will not be surprised by future regulations. Because the time for voluntary action is running out – and the future of urban land use planning is resilient or not at all.

Practice and innovation: How resilience is transforming planning practice

Resilient urban land use planning is not an abstract goal, but has long been a reality – at least in those municipalities that are actively shaping change. A look at current projects shows how diverse the approaches are: In Hamburg, for example, the development of new neighborhoods systematically examines how areas affect heavy rainfall, summer heat and air quality. Green corridors, infiltration areas and fresh air corridors are not only “co-planned”, but are also seen as key structural factors.

In Zurich, digital tools are being used to anchor resilience in urban development. Digital city models, sensor data and AI-supported simulations make it possible to test various climate scenarios and flexibly adapt measures. This makes it possible to avoid planning errors and identify potential at an early stage – a real quantum leap compared to traditional paper-based planning.

Vienna is also showing how resilience is changing urban design as a guiding principle: By integrating participatory processes, not only expert knowledge but also local experience and everyday skills are brought into the planning process. This increases acceptance and makes measures more sustainable. Resilience is thus becoming the cornerstone of a new, learning planning culture.

Technological innovations are playing an increasingly important role in this: urban digital twins, geoinformation systems and open data platforms provide the basis for data-driven resilience strategies. Instead of static plans, dynamic decision-making bases are being created that can react to current developments. This opens up completely new possibilities for planners – but also requires new skills and responsibilities.

What is important here is that resilience is not an end in itself and not a purely technical issue. It must always be considered in the context of social, ecological and economic goals. Only then can real added value be created – for the city, the people and the environment. The best examples show this: Where resilience is consistently implemented, the result is not only greater security, but also a better quality of life and innovation.

Risks, opportunities and governance – who controls the resilient future?

The legal anchoring of resilience harbors enormous opportunities – but also risks. On the one hand, it can help cities and municipalities to be better prepared for crises, minimize damage and implement innovations more quickly. On the other hand, there is a risk that resilience will degenerate into a mere compulsory exercise or be suffocated by technocratic overregulation. The balance between legal requirements and local freedom is crucial.

Governance is a key issue: who defines what resilient planning means? Which stakeholders are involved? And how can conflicting goals between climate adaptation, social justice and economic development be resolved? Clear responsibilities, transparent processes and an open dialog between administration, politics, business and civil society are needed here.

The integration of new technologies raises additional questions: How will data be collected, used and protected? Who has control over digital city models and simulation tools? What role do commercial providers play? Data protection, data sovereignty and digital participation are key challenges that need to be addressed at an early stage.

Another risk: resilience must not become a mere empty phrase. If it is not backed up with concrete goals, measurable indicators and effective measures, it risks becoming an excuse for inactivity. At the same time, there is a risk that vulnerable groups will be overlooked and that “resilient” solutions will primarily serve the interests of financially strong players. A watchful eye is needed here – and a willingness to see resilience as a social model that involves everyone.

However, the opportunities outweigh the risks: those who take resilience seriously can not only make cities safer, but also more liveable, more innovative and fairer. This requires the courage to break new ground, question old routines and make participation a fundamental principle. Resilient urban land use planning is not a goal, but an ongoing process – open, learning and adaptable.

Outlook: The resilient city as a new model for urban land use planning

The future of urban land use planning has long since arrived – it is resilient, networked and data-driven. What is still being discussed as a vision today could become a binding standard tomorrow. The legal basis for this is currently being created. It is crucial that planners, administrations and politicians actively shape the change – and do not wait until crises force them to do so.

Resilience as a legal standard requires a paradigm shift: away from linear control and towards flexible, adaptive processes. Away from pure hazard prevention and towards proactively shaping the urban future. This will only succeed if all stakeholders pull together and see resilience as a joint task.

Technology, digitalization and data integration are indispensable tools – but they are no substitute for creative planning, social innovation and participatory governance. The best solutions are created where expert knowledge and civic experience, high-tech and low-tech, vision and reality come together.

The resilient city is not a static goal, but a permanent process. It thrives on experiments, mistakes and learning loops. Urban land use planning must therefore become more open, flexible and courageous. Those who invest now – in knowledge, cooperation and infrastructure – will not only survive the city of tomorrow, they will shape it.

Garten und Landschaft keeps its finger on the pulse – with expertise, vision and a pinch of self-irony. Because the future of urban land use planning is anything but boring. It is challenging, exciting and full of opportunities. Let’s make resilience the new standard – not just in law, but at the heart of planning culture.

Summary: The future of urban land use planning is facing a fundamental transformation: resilience is becoming the new standard and could soon become mandatory by law. The integration of resilience into planning requires a paradigm shift – away from rigid specifications and towards flexible, learning processes. Legal, technological and social developments are driving this change. It is crucial that planners, administrations and society take responsibility together, dare to innovate and establish resilience as a central guiding principle. This is the only way that cities and regions can confidently meet the challenges of the climate crisis, urbanization and social change. Resilient urban land use planning is not a sure-fire success – but it is the best insurance for the future of our cities.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Berlin, Hotel nhow

Building design

At the nhow hotel, Karim Rashid combines pink Barbie dreams with exclusive design. Right on the Spree, at the epicenter of music, fashion and the creative scene

Karim Rashid combines pink Barbiet dreams with exclusive design. It’s not everyone’s cup of tea. The hotel brochure states that this is the epicenter of the music, fashion and creative scene on the Spree – and right in the middle of it all is this new lifestyle hotel. There’s no escaping the cosmopolitan jet set, the party animals and the hottest bands, the advertising drones on. But when you’re looking for your destination from the S-Bahn along the noisy, shabby streets, you’re not sure whether you got off in Herne or Bottrop. This is Berlin. East.

The large hotel building next to the old restored Spreespeicher takes up its scale, a broad block with a relief-like structured brick façade that stretches three times over a terrace towards the water and offers a tilting top floor as an aperçu. This cantilevers 21 meters into the void and has a mirrored underside. When you wake up in a room below, you immediately feel a bad hangover because the Spree with its reservoirs now appears very high, inverted and distorted. This outer shell was designed by nps tchoban voss and could also be a solid hotel standard.

What the operator was looking for above all, however, were the ideas of New York designer Karim Rashid. He poured a cornucopia of shrill furnishings into the brick box, which he blurred under digipop, blobject, infosthetic and similar techno semantics. Goodbye, good form! To describe how these pastel-colored congealed soft parts make themselves useful as fixtures would go beyond the scope of this column. Think of a perfumery, a sex store for women and Baby-Walz. In 3D, this leads to an amoeba-like portal counter in the foyer, from which discreetly costumed, very friendly ladies peer out to help you. The delicious breakfast buffet is also presented in such a raspberry-colored plastic entrails. Silver shell seats at the bar, cushion-like upholstery and a shiny ceiling like an ostrich egg carton define the place where the music plays on Saturdays.

It’s all part of the concept. You can listen to music and play it yourself on keyboards or Gibson guitars, which you can borrow. There are two professional studios on the top floor. But that doesn’t mean you’ll be sitting next to Rihanna or Beyoncé at the bar. This is also where representatives enjoy their cultural Berlin allowance after the trade fair. The rooms are very solid and well equipped. You could race in a wheelchair in the superior bathroom, but working at the small table on washable upholstered frames is less of an option. The television is hidden behind a mirror, the bed is high and certainly healthy. Only the omnipresent patterns, reminiscent of a pause sign from early ARD, make you sick.

Address

Hotel nhow Berlin
Stralauer Allee 3
10245 Berlin
www.nhow-hotels.com

Brasília’s photographer: Marcel Gautherot

Building design
Palácio Alvorada

Facade of the Palácio Alvorada

“Marcel Gautherot was our favorite photographer for many years.” This quote comes from Oscar Niemeyer and shows the close bond between the two.

“Marcel Gautherot was our favorite photographer for many years. We designed the buildings, he photographed them… And the photos he took… How skillfully he hit the right angles and the contrasts in the architecture, of which he knew so much!”

This quote comes from Oscar Niemeyer, who worked closely with Gautherot. While the photographer did not achieve great fame during his lifetime, the architect was a man in demand. This can be explained by the fact that photography was only introduced to the art world in Brazil at a late stage. Picture agencies were also only founded at this time.

Today, Gautherot is considered more important. His work is considered a fundamental part of the history of modern architectural photography. After all, Marcel Gautherot was present at the major events of modernism. This began when he started studying architecture at night school in 1925, when Le Corbusier and Pierre Jeanneret set an example against the decorative arts with the Pavillon l’Esprit Nouveau for the World Exhibition of Decorative Arts and Industrial Design. Gautherot was 15 years old at the time, so he experienced the upheavals in the modern architecture movement from a young age.

These influences can be seen in an article he wrote for the magazine Discours sur l’architecture française. This reflects Corbusier’s view that “architecture is a clever, correct and magnificent interplay of unified structures in the light” and that light is the “foundation of architecture”. The content of the article already announces the inseparability of architecture and photography in Gautherot’s work. This was confirmed many years later with his statement: “Photography is architecture.” Someone who knows nothing about architecture is not capable of making good photography.

Gautherot began photographing the most important representatives of modernism in Brazil. Between 1942 and 44, he documented the Pampulha complex by Niemeyer in Belo Horizonte. The building was commissioned by the mayor of the city, Juscelino Kubitschek. Years later, he was president of the state and, together with Niemeyer, responsible for the construction of Brasilia. Gautherot was also responsible for the photographic documentation of the construction of the city at this key moment in Brazilian architectural history.

And although photography was not yet particularly recognized as an art, it was used as a tool to publicize and promote modern architecture (such as Lucien Hervés’ images for Le Corbusier’s planned city of Chandigarh). Advertising was also necessary in the case of Brasília – after all, the city had to be filled with inhabitants, which for many meant moving away from Rio.

When Gautherot photographed Brasília, he was 50 years old – a seasoned photographer. Nevertheless, it can be said that he found his style early on. Throughout his career, he maintained a consistent point of view and the unusual composition of his pictures.

A special feature of his pictures is the square format. This resulted from the use of the Rolleiflex, which exposes in square negative format (6 x 6 cm). For the viewer, there is no horizontal or vertical orientation in this format. The view creates a balance.

Gautherot had a perfect command of the static language of the square. He builds on its diagonals, introduces angles of 45 degrees, divides the surface into two parts by the horizontal (sometimes vertical) and places a central figure at the center. And this is precisely why the pictures of Brasília are so explosive: Gautherot’s style merges with Niemeyer’s large mathematical curves (parabolas and hyperbolas) – in the documentation of the construction work as well as the finished buildings.

Marcel Gautherot was born in France in 1910 and lived in Brazil from 1940. Between 1934 and 1935, he undertook his first photo trip to Greece at his own expense. This was followed by Mexico – and finally Brazil in 1939, where he photographed the Amazon region. His military service in the Second World War forced him to leave Brazil, but he returned in 1940 – and stayed. In old age, Gautherot explained that he came to photography primarily because he wanted to travel.

Marcel Gautherot’s artistic photographic path, which also includes travel and landscape impressions, portrait photography, ethnological pictorial explorations and everyday shots, is portrayed in the book “Marcel Gautherot”, published by Schneidegger & Spiess, using 200 photographs from all his creative phases and enriched with essays by international experts.